This checklist covers widely-used formatting standards, but every program differs. Always confirm your thesis format against your own graduate school's official formatting manual or template before submitting or depositing. Your committee chair or graduate office can point you to the exact requirements for your degree.
Front Matter Order
The pages before your main text must appear in the correct sequence. Check that you have included all required pages and that they are in the order your program specifies.
Margins & Pagination
Consistent spacing and page numbering are critical. Many formatting rejections result from inconsistent margins or misplaced page numbers.
Fonts & Spacing
Consistent typography throughout your thesis signals professionalism and meets most formatting guidelines.
Figures & Tables
Every figure and table must be properly numbered, captioned, and cited in your text before it appears.
Citations & References
Consistency in citation style is a frequent area of review. Choose your citation style (APA, Chicago, MLA, etc.) and apply it uniformly.
Digital Submission
If submitting or depositing your thesis as a PDF (e.g., to ProQuest or your institution's repository), verify digital requirements.
Why Formatting Rejections Happen
Graduate schools' formatting review processes flag recurring issues. The most common reasons for revision requests are:
- Inconsistent margins. Mixed left margins (especially when binding allowance is required) are the top reason for rejection. Every page must match.
- Missing or out-of-order front matter. A misplaced table of contents or missing copyright page stops a submission immediately.
- Uncaptioned figures and tables. If a figure lacks a caption or is unreferenced in text, it will be sent back.
- Mixed citation styles. Switching between APA and Chicago mid-thesis, or formatting references inconsistently, triggers a full re-review.
- Incorrect page numbering. Using Arabic numerals in front matter or Roman numerals in body text will be caught and rejected.
- Font embedding issues in PDFs. Non-embedded fonts render differently on another system, causing the PDF to be resubmitted.
Most of these are preventable by using your program's template or checklist and running a careful final pass before submission.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is my checklist data saved anywhere but my browser?
Does this replace my university's own formatting review?
What is the most common reason theses get sent back for reformatting?
Should I check my formatting before or after my defense?
My program uses LaTeX. Does this checklist still apply?
Sources
This checklist is based on widely-recognized thesis formatting conventions used across U.S. graduate programs, particularly those aligned with Chicago Manual of Style and Purdue OWL guidance. Specific requirements vary by institution:
- Purdue OWL: MLA Formatting and Style Guide
- Purdue OWL: APA Formatting and Style Guide
- The Chicago Manual of Style (standard for humanities theses)
- Individual university thesis formatting manuals and ProQuest submission guidelines (institution-specific)
Always verify against your own graduate school's formatting manual before final submission.